“ Diners aren't usually my first choice, but a friend and I went here before seeing a movie at the Burns Film Center and I have to say it's probably the most pleasant (pun intended) diner experience I have had. The atmosphere is mid-century retro and extremely clean (I've been to some diners in the past that left much to be desired in the realm cleanliness--and it's a wonder I took chances eating there). I had the California Wrap and, for only $1.50 more, substituted sweet potato fries. The wrap was pressed like a panini and stuffed to the max with chunks of chicken, lettuce, tomato, bacon and some avocado. The wrap was huge--each half was enough for one meal--and came with cole slaw and a dill pickle wedge. The sweet potato fries were ok. A bit mushy. I like them a little crispier than served. My friend had the buffalo chicken salad and enjoyed it. The service is courteous. We did wait a bit for our food. If we hadn't been on our way to see a film, I don't think I would have minded the pacing...you need it for the portions they give you here! If Guy Frieri makes a stop here, do let me know! ”

“ I love this diner! Service was quick and friendly. Food was delicious and the portions were large. Classic diner experience. ”

“ Great food, great service. Very enjoyable. The diner is very clean. I sat at the counter, and the staff was very friendly. I ordered their Very Berry Turkey Burger. Most Turkey burgers can be dry...this was not dry at all...I required several napkins. Served with fresh Cole slaw and pickle. It had a side of sweet potato fries that were crispy and had a hint of cinnamon.. it went great with my coffee. Before I left, they sent me out the door with a complimentary slice of delicious chocolate cake....one of the best diner experiences I've had in a long time. I can't wait to go back. ”

“ I came here on a Saturday at noon. The service here was very prompt and attentive. I ordered the gyro which was quite flavorful. My son ordered Oreo pancakes which was really well done. Everyone here was gracious. The price was a bit higher than most diners nearby, given the level of service and commitment by the staff it was worth every penny. The new owner has maintained a high quality here. The inside feels like a traditional diner. ”

“ New owners made all the difference. I now give it five stars Great service; great menu. I bring all my friends and family there You can't go wrong And they have parking !!!!!!yippee ”

“ I loved the diner ambiance here! Felt like an old school diner but with an elevated clean interior. I got a breakfast burrito, it was yummy! Also they were very accommodating with me taking a meeting here. Wifi worked very well. ”

“ My husband and i hadn't been back to Pleasantville Diner since before the pandemic. We had a not so great experience and just had figured the new owners (at the time) were not keeping it at the level it had once been. Well I recently heard it had changed owners again and we decided to give it another try. The interior as of yet has not changed much. Some art on the walls (in the back) had changed but that's about it. It looks like they are waiting for some new tables and chairs. The menu has been downsized from what was a traditional diner sized menu. It had a lot of great options. My husband ordered the Turkey BLT Panini and I ordered a Greek omelet. His entree presented well, as did my omelet. The Turkey looked like it was cut off freshly roasted Turkey breast! It was a generous portion. The fries were delicious as well. My Greek omelet was well prepared and tasted delicious. I also enjoyed the home fries! The service was great, very attentive! At the end of our meal the owner brought over two desserts, on the house, for us to try at home! What a wonderful surprise! Looking forward to enjoying them tomorrow with our family! Our only issue was the prices are a bit high for a diner, but that seems to be the case in most diners in the area. We will be back. ”